Commit Graph

5 Commits

Author SHA1 Message Date
k8s-merge-robot
5643b7498f Merge pull request #25881 from jsafrane/devel/pv-add-cache
Automatic merge from submit-queue

volume controller: Add cache with the latest version of PVs and PVCs

When the controller binds a PV to PVC, it saves both objects to etcd. However, there is still an old version of these objects in the controller Informer cache. So, when a new PVC comes, the PV is still seen as available and may get bound to the new PVC. This will be blocked by etcd, still, it creates unnecessary traffic that slows everything down.

To make everything worse, when periodic sync with the old PVC is performed, this PVC is seen by the controller as Pending (while it's already Bound on etcd) and will be bound to a different PV. Writing to this PV won't be blocked by etcd, only subsequent write of the PVC fails. So, the controller will need to roll back the PV in another transaction(s). The controller can keep itself pretty busy this way.

Also, we save bound PVs (and PVCs) as two transactions - we save say PV.Spec first and then .Status. The controller gets "PV.Spec updated" event from etcd and tries to fix the Status, as it seems to the controller it's outdated. This write again fails - there already is a correct version in etcd.

As we can't influence the Informer cache, it is read-only to the controller, this patch introduces second cache in the controller, which holds latest and greatest version on PVs and PVCs to prevent these useless writes to etcd . It gets updated with events from etcd *and* after etcd confirms successful save of PV/PVC modified by the controller.

The cache stores only *pointers* to PVs/PVCs, so in ideal case it shares the actual object data with the informer cache. They will diverge only for a short time when the controller modifies something and the informer cache did not get update events yet.

@kubernetes/sig-storage
2016-05-30 04:13:18 -07:00
Brendan Burns
88663fc58b Add some extra checking in the tests to prevent flakes. 2016-05-23 16:25:02 -07:00
Jan Safranek
0279232360 volume controller: Add cache with the latest version of PVs and PVCs
When the controller binds a PV to PVC, it saves both objects to etcd.
However, there is still an old version of these objects in the controller
Informer cache. So, when a new PVC comes, the PV is still seen as available
and may get bound to the new PVC. This will be blocked by etcd, still, it
creates unnecessary traffic that slows everything down.

Also, we save bound PV/PVC as two transactions - we save PV/PVC.Spec first
and then .Status. The controller gets "PV/PVC.Spec updated" event from etcd
and tries to fix the Status, as it seems to the controller it's outdated.
This write again fails - there already is a correct version in etcd.

We can't influence the Informer cache, it is read-only to the controller.

To prevent these useless writes to etcd, this patch introduces second cache
in the controller, which holds latest and greatest version on PVs and PVCs.
It gets updated with events from etcd *and* after etcd confirms successful
save of PV/PVC modified by the controller.

The cache stores only *pointers* to PVs/PVCs, so in ideal case it shares the
actual object data with the informer cache. They will diverge only when
the controller modifies something and the informer cache did not get update
events yet.
2016-05-19 16:09:06 +02:00
Jan Safranek
79b91b9ee0 Refactor persistent volume initialization
There should be only one initialization function, shared by the real
controller and unit tests.
2016-05-18 10:06:51 +02:00
Jan Safranek
7f549511e2 Big move and rename
- remove persistentvolume_ prefix from all files
- split controller.go into controller.go and controller_base.go (to have them
  under 1500 lines for github)
2016-05-18 10:06:51 +02:00