This is a first step towards removing the mock CSI driver completely from
e2e testing in favor of hostpath plugin. With the recent hostpath plugin
changes(PR #260, #269), it supports all the features supported by the mock
csi driver.
Using hostpath-plugin for testing also covers CSI persistent feature
usecases.
Besides "subPath should unmount if pod is gracefully deleted while kubelet is
down" we also need a special case for "subPath should unmount if pod is force
deleted while kubelet is down".
This fixes a test failure in https://testgrid.k8s.io/sig-storage-kubernetes#gce-serial
This reverts commit
c15fd76ee9. Most (all?) of the hostpath
tests and several other tests started to fail again in
gce-scale-master-correctness after re-enabling the controller. This
shows that it was not just the obsolete agent which causes scalability
problems, but also the controller.
It has to be disabled until the scalability problems are addressed.
It was disabled together with the agent to avoid test failures in
gce-master-scale-correctness (https://github.com/kubernetes/kubernetes/issues/102452). That
solved the problem, but we still need to check whether the controller
alone works.
They are not needed for any of the tests and may be causing too much
overhead (see
https://github.com/kubernetes/kubernetes/issues/102452#issuecomment-854452816).
We already disabled them earlier and then re-enabled them again
because it wasn't clear how much overhead they were causing. A recent
change in how the sidecars get
deployed (https://github.com/kubernetes/kubernetes/pull/102282) seems
to have made the situation worse again. There's no logical explanation
for that yet, though.
(cherry picked from commit 0c2cee5676e64976f9e767f40c4c4750a8eeb11f)
This reverts commit 0c2cee5676e64976f9e767f40c4c4750a8eeb11f.
The health check containers are not required for any test, but we want
to run them anyway to ensure that they cause no unexpected issues.
In one mock test, the snapshotter needs permission to read
secrets. That was disabled in the RBAC files of recent releases. We
need to patch it back in during deployment.
They are not needed for any of the tests and in practice apparently
caused enough overhead that even unrelated tests timed out. For
example, in the pull-kubernetes-e2e-kind test, 43 out of 5771 tests
failed, including tests from sig-node, sig-cli, sig-api-machinery,
sig-network.
Mirroring the various YAML files by hand is tedious. The new
update-hostpath.sh does all the necessary steps automatically.
The result is now a bit more consistent with the upstream repos in the
sense that the original file names and paths for the RBAC YAML files
are used.
The csi-hostpath-testing.yaml is included for the sake of
completeness, but not used during E2E testing.
The new hostpath driver release is v1.6.2, which adds the
external-health-monitor for the first time.
This replaces embedding of JavaScript code into the mock driver that
runs inside the cluster with Go callbacks which run inside the
e2e.test suite itself. In contrast to the JavaScript hooks, they have
direct access to all parameters and can fabricate arbitrary responses,
not just error codes.
Because the callbacks run in the same process as the test itself, it
is possible to set up two-way communication via shared variables or
channels. This opens the door for writing better tests. Some of the
existing tests that poll mock driver output could be simplified, but
that can be addressed later.
For now, only tests using hooks use embedding. How gRPC calls are
retrieved is abstracted behind the CSIMockTestDriver interface, so
tests don't need to be modified when switching between embedding
and remote mock driver.
Extract TestSuite, TestDriver, TestPattern, TestConfig
and VolumeResource, SnapshotVolumeResource from testsuite
package and put them into a new package called api.
The ultimate goal here is to make the testsuites as clean
as possible. And only testsuites in the package.
In our current mock CSI driver e2e test, we are not waiting
for the CSI driver register successfully to perform test
including provision PVC. This can lead to timeout when the
csi driver takes longer to register the socket.
This change adds the waiting part so that the system will
wait for up to 10 minutes for the driver to be ready. This
normally won't take this long. However, under a resource
constraint environment it can take longer than expected time.
https://github.com/kubernetes/kubernetes/issues/93358
The way gingko handles interrupts is:
- It starts running AfterSuite hooks in a separate goroutine (this includes cleanupAction hooks)
- Once AfterSuite hook is done executing it calls
os.Exit(1) on test suite.
So how cleanupFunc() that runs via defer in test can be interrupted
is:
- cleanupFunc starts running via defer (or AfterEach hook) but first
thing that function does is to remove cleanupHandle from
framework.RemoveCleanupAction.
- Test suite receives interrupt from user and AfterSuite block
starts executing
- remember that while cleanupFunc is running in goroutine#1,
AfterSuite is running concurrently in goroutine#2.
- AfterSuite hook has bunch of CleanupActions it needs to run which
were registered via framework.AddCleanupAction(cleanupFunc) but
once cleanupFunc starts executing via defer in the test, it will
remove the cleanupHandle from framework's aftersuite hooks.
- So if AfterSuite did not had anything to run (because
those actions were removed via framework.RemoveCleanupAction
then it will simply go to the last framework.AfterEach action and call os.Exit(1)
- So if os.Exit(1) is called before cleanupFunc has a chance to finish in defer, it will not complete.
The mock driver gets instructed to return a ResourceExhausted error
for the first CreateVolume invocation via the storage class
parameters.
How this should be handled depends on the situation: for normal
volumes, we just want external-scheduler to retry. For late binding,
we want to reschedule the pod. It also depends on topology support.
Especially related to "uncertain" global mounts. A large refactoring of CSI
mock tests were necessary:
- to be able to script the driver to return errors as required by the test
- to parse the CSI driver logs to check kubelet called the right CSI calls
