Files
regorus/docs/rvm/instruction-set.md
Mark Birger f0acc64195 feat(compiler): support registered host-await builtins for natural function call syntax (#667)
* feat(compiler): support registered host-await builtins

Allow hosts to register function names at compile time so that calls to
those names emit HostAwait instructions directly, enabling natural syntax
like fetch(x) instead of __builtin_host_await(x, "fetch").

- Add host_await_builtins map and register_host_await_builtin() to Compiler
- Validate arg_count == 1 and reject reserved __builtin_host_await name
- Extend determine_call_target() resolution: explicit > registered > user > builtin
- Both explicit and registered paths emit identical HostAwait bytecode
- Add compile_from_policy_with_host_await() entry point in rules.rs
- Extended test harness with HostAwaitBuiltinSpec and args assertion
- 9 YAML test cases: suspend/resume, run-to-completion, multiple names,
  queue, shadowing, object packing, arg_count rejection, reserved name
  rejection, standard builtin override
- Documentation: instruction-set.md, architecture.md

* Update src/languages/rego/compiler/function_calls.rs

Co-authored-by: Copilot <175728472+Copilot@users.noreply.github.com>
Signed-off-by: Mark Birger <birgerm@yandex.ru>

* fix(compiler): address PR #667 review feedback on host-await registration

- Compiler::register_host_await_builtin now rejects duplicate, empty,
  and whitespace-only names. Previously a duplicate registration would
  silently overwrite the existing entry, which could mask the host's
  own registration mistakes.
- YAML test cases added: empty registration list as no-op, duplicate
  name rejection, empty/whitespace name rejection, out-param (a, out)
  calling syntax with a single-arg registered builtin, and mixed
  __builtin_host_await + registered builtins in the same policy
  consuming from their respective identifier queues.
- Test harness: replace assert_eq! on HostAwait argument mismatch with
  anyhow::Error so mismatches propagate through the case reporter
  instead of panicking and skipping the harness's normal error path.
- YAML comment fix: "Registration panics" -> "Registration fails with
  an error" (registration returns Err, never panics).

Addresses anakrish + Copilot inline review comments on PR #667.

Co-authored-by: Copilot <223556219+Copilot@users.noreply.github.com>

* compiler: split CallTarget::HostAwait into explicit and registered variants

Addresses PR #667 review item #8: at the emit site in
`compile_function_call`, the discrimination between explicit
`__builtin_host_await(arg, id)` and a registered host-awaitable
builtin was being recovered by string-comparing `original_fcn_path`
against `"__builtin_host_await"`. The information was already known
in `determine_call_target` and was being thrown away.

Replace the single `CallTarget::HostAwait` variant with two:

* `ExplicitHostAwait` (unit) — the two-argument call form. The
  identifier register comes from the user's second argument.
* `RegisteredHostAwait { identifier: String }` — the one-argument
  call form for registered builtins. The identifier is the registered
  name and is captured in the variant at recognition time, so the
  emit site never re-derives it from the function path.

This removes the magic-string comparison at the emit site (the source
of truth is now `determine_call_target`) and makes both match sites
in `compile_function_call` exhaustive over the two forms — adding a
third host-await form in the future would force a compile error at
every match site instead of silently falling through.

Arities are now hardcoded in the `expected_args` extraction
(`Some(2)` for explicit, `Some(1)` for registered) rather than
carried in the variant; registered builtins are constrained to
`arg_count == 1` at registration time, so there is no per-call
variability to carry.

Bytecode output is unchanged; the full RVM test suite (97 cases) and
the registered_host_await suite (15 cases) pass without modification.

Co-authored-by: Copilot <223556219+Copilot@users.noreply.github.com>

* docs(compiler): clarify registered host-await intercepts unqualified calls only

PR #667 review (Medium): the docs implied registered host-await names
shadow user functions and builtins unconditionally, but
determine_call_target matches only the bare original_fcn_path. A
package-qualified call such as data.demo.resolve(x) is therefore not
intercepted -- it resolves through the normal path like any other call.

Rather than expand registration to qualified paths (which would let a
registered name leak into every package exposing a same-named rule),
document the unqualified-only behavior and pin it with tests.

- register_host_await_builtin: doc now states only the unqualified call
  form is intercepted; qualified calls resolve normally.
- determine_call_target: inline comment explaining the deliberate
  original_fcn_path-only match.
- docs/rvm/instruction-set.md: describe qualified-call resolution,
  including that builtins have no qualified form.
- tests: cross-package and same-package qualified calls resolve to the
  rule; bare-name shadowing of a standard builtin; Unknown-function
  outcome when no rule exists at the qualified path.

Co-authored-by: Copilot <223556219+Copilot@users.noreply.github.com>

* fix(tests): compare host-await argument without re-running process_value

PR #667 review (Low): the suspendable test harness compared the
host-await argument via process_value(argument), but argument is already
a runtime Value. process_value is a YAML-fixture decoder -- it rewrites
"#undefined" to Undefined, {set!: [...]} to a set, and errors on a
runtime Value::Set. Re-running it on the runtime argument could coerce a
legitimate payload into a fixture sentinel (passing for the wrong
reason) or error outright on sets.

Compare the runtime argument directly against the expected value, which
is already decoded once at YAML load time.

Add a regression case (registered_builtin_suspendable_set_argument) that
passes a set payload: it fails under the old double-processing
("unexpected set in value read from json/yaml") and passes with the fix.

Co-authored-by: Copilot <223556219+Copilot@users.noreply.github.com>

* fix(tests): reject `args:` payload expectations in run-to-completion mode

PR #667 review (Low): a run-to-completion host-await response could carry
an `args:` payload expectation, but RTC execution pre-loads responses and
never surfaces the call argument to the harness, so the expectation was
parsed and silently dropped. A case with `args: "WRONG"` passed as long as
the result matched -- asserting a payload that was never checked.

Reject `args:` for run-to-completion fixtures at load time, directing the
author to suspendable mode where arguments are validated. Also only build
the run-to-completion response vector when the case actually runs in RTC
mode, so a suspendable case using the shared host_await_responses field
with `args:` is not wrongly rejected.

Route the fixture-load error through the same want_error handling used for
compilation errors, and add registered_builtin_run_to_completion_rejects_args
which now fails loudly instead of passing silently.

Co-authored-by: Copilot <223556219+Copilot@users.noreply.github.com>

* fix(compiler): reject host-await builtin names with surrounding whitespace

PR #667 review (Low): register_host_await_builtin rejected all-whitespace
names via name.trim().is_empty(), but accepted padded names like " lookup"
or "lookup ". Those were inserted into host_await_builtins, but Rego
function-call paths produce the trimmed identifier, so a padded
registration could never match -- a silent dead registration.

Reject any name that is not already trimmed (name != name.trim()) in
addition to empty names, and update the error message accordingly. Add
test cases for leading and trailing whitespace.

Co-authored-by: Copilot <223556219+Copilot@users.noreply.github.com>

---------

Signed-off-by: Mark Birger <birgerm@yandex.ru>
Co-authored-by: Mark Birger <markbirger@microsoft.com>
Co-authored-by: Copilot <175728472+Copilot@users.noreply.github.com>
Co-authored-by: Copilot <223556219+Copilot@users.noreply.github.com>
2026-06-29 11:17:25 -05:00

19 KiB

RVM Instruction Set Reference

This reference captures every opcode emitted by the compiler and executed by RegoVM. Each instruction is defined in src/rvm/instructions/mod.rs and implemented by the dispatcher tree in src/rvm/vm/dispatch.rs plus specialised submodules (arithmetic.rs, loops.rs, functions.rs, rules.rs, comprehension.rs, virtual_data.rs).

Use this guide to understand operand semantics, parameter tables, and runtime side effects.


Reading the tables

  • Operands: registers (rX), literals (litY), parameter indices (pZ) and immediate values.
  • Parameters: links into InstructionData (src/rvm/instructions/params.rs). The compiler stores complex metadata here; instructions reference it by index.
  • Outcome: mentioned in prose where relevant (Continue, Return, Break, Suspend).

Load and Move instructions

Mnemonic Operands Behaviour
Load dest=rD, literal_idx=litN Copies literal N into register D.
LoadTrue dest=rD Stores boolean true.
LoadFalse dest=rD Stores boolean false.
LoadNull dest=rD Stores Value::Null.
LoadBool dest=rD, value Stores inline boolean literal.
LoadData dest=rD Stores the VM's data value.
LoadInput dest=rD Stores the VM's input value.
Move dest=rD, src=rS Copies register S into register D.

Out-of-range literal indices raise VmError::LiteralIndexOutOfBounds. Registers must have been allocated by the current frame.


Arithmetic and comparison instructions

Mnemonic Operands Behaviour
Add dest, left, right Numeric addition; undefined operands trigger loop condition checks.
Sub dest, left, right Numeric subtraction.
Mul dest, left, right Numeric multiplication.
Div dest, left, right Numeric division with runtime checks (division by zero errors).
Mod dest, left, right Modulo.
Eq dest, left, right Equality comparison resulting in Value::Bool.
Ne dest, left, right Inequality.
Lt/Le/Gt/Ge dest, left, right Ordering comparisons.
And dest, left, right Logical conjunction (truthiness semantics).
Or dest, left, right Logical disjunction.
Not dest, operand Logical negation.
AssertCondition condition Fails current loop/rule when the condition is falsey.
AssertNotUndefined register Fails when register holds Value::Undefined.

handle_condition routes through loops.rs to propagate failures to loop and comprehension contexts. Outside loops it aborts the current rule.


Collection and indexing instructions

Mnemonic Operands / Params Behaviour
ObjectSet obj, key, value Mutates object in obj with key/value from registers.
ObjectCreate params_index=pN Builds object from literal template and register entries.
ArrayNew dest Creates empty array.
ArrayPush arr, value Appends to array.
ArrayCreate params_index=pN Builds array from register list; undefined element ⇒ result undefined.
SetNew dest Creates empty set.
SetAdd set, value Adds element to set.
SetCreate params_index=pN Builds set from register list; undefined element ⇒ result undefined.
Index dest, container, key Indexes container with runtime key.
IndexLiteral dest, container, literal_idx Indexes container using literal stored in program.
ChainedIndex params_index=pN Resolves multi-hop path from root register.
Contains dest, collection, value Checks membership; returns Value::Bool.
Count dest, collection Returns length or Value::Undefined for unsupported types.
VirtualDataDocumentLookup params_index=pN Evaluates data path, invoking rules lazily.

Parameter structures:

  • ObjectCreateParams reuses arrays of literal key/value pairs and register pairs. Literal keys must be sorted to match template order.
  • ArrayCreateParams and SetCreateParams store register lists. The VM checks all referenced registers for Value::Undefined before constructing the collection.
  • VirtualDataDocumentLookupParams and ChainedIndexParams encode Vec<LiteralOrRegister> path components. LiteralOrRegister is defined in src/rvm/instructions/types.rs.

Loop instructions

Loops use dedicated parameter tables (LoopStartParams) and the LoopMode enum.

Mnemonic Operands / Params Behaviour
LoopStart params_index=pN Initialises loop context and decides first body iteration.
LoopNext body_start, loop_end Finalises iteration, updates accumulators, advances to next element.

LoopMode values:

  • Any: succeed on first passing iteration, short-circuit on success.
  • Every: fail on first failing iteration.
  • ForEach: evaluate all iterations, typically for comprehensions or complete rules.

LoopStartParams fields:

  • collection: source register.
  • key_reg / value_reg: iteration registers (for arrays, key is index).
  • result_reg: accumulator storing loop outcome (bool for quantifiers).
  • body_start / loop_end: PCs identifying loop boundaries.

The dispatcher converts LoopStartParams into a VM-specific LoopParams used by both execution modes. In suspendable mode, loops own their own ExecutionFrame.


Comprehension instructions

Mnemonic Operands / Params Behaviour
ComprehensionBegin params_index=pN Allocates collection builder and iteration context.
ComprehensionYield value_reg, key_reg? Emits value (and optional key) into builder.
ComprehensionEnd Finalises collection and stores result.

ComprehensionBeginParams captures:

  • mode: ComprehensionMode (Set, Array, Object)
  • collection_reg: source register for iteration
  • result_reg: register that will hold the final collection
  • key_reg / value_reg: iteration registers
  • body_start / comprehension_end: branch targets

Comprehensions manage their own stack (ComprehensionContext) to maintain ordering guarantees (arrays), uniqueness (sets) or key/value pairing (objects).


Call and return instructions

Mnemonic Operands / Params Behaviour
BuiltinCall params_index=pN Invokes builtin via resolved function pointer.
FunctionCall params_index=pN Invokes function rule.
CallRule dest, rule_index Requests rule evaluation with caching.
RuleInit result_reg, rule_index Prepares rule accumulator and cache state.
Return value_reg Returns value from current function body.
RuleReturn Finalises rule evaluation frame.
DestructuringSuccess Signals successful destructuring, breaks rule block.

Parameter tables:

  • BuiltinCallParams / FunctionCallParams store destination register, index into builtin table / rule index, argument count and up to eight argument register numbers.
  • The VM dynamically resizes registers when a callee requires a larger window using program metadata (max_rule_window_size).

Host interaction

Mnemonic Operands Behaviour
HostAwait dest, arg, id Yields control to host with payload value.
  • Run-to-completion: consumes a response from host_await_responses keyed by the identifier register. Missing responses raise VmError::HostAwaitResponseMissing.
  • Suspendable: emits InstructionOutcome::Suspend with SuspendReason::HostAwait. The host must resume with a value that will be written into dest.

Registered host-await builtins

The compiler can be configured with a list of function names that map directly to HostAwait instructions. This allows policy authors to write natural function calls (e.g. lookup(input.account_id)) instead of the raw __builtin_host_await(payload, identifier) builtin.

Registration is done at compile time via Compiler::compile_from_policy_with_host_await:

let builtins = [("lookup", 1), ("persist", 1)];
let program = Compiler::compile_from_policy_with_host_await(
    &compiled_policy, &entry_points, &builtins,
)?;

Each registered name is a (name, arg_count) pair. When the compiler encounters a call to a registered name, it emits a HostAwait instruction with:

  • arg = the first argument register
  • id = a register loaded with a string literal containing the function name

Both the explicit __builtin_host_await(arg, id) call and a registered builtin call produce the same HostAwait bytecode instruction. The only difference is how the id register is populated: explicit calls take it from the second user-supplied argument, while registered calls auto-generate a Load instruction for the function name string. The VM cannot distinguish between the two at runtime.

Resolution order in determine_call_target():

  1. __builtin_host_await (magic 2-argument form)
  2. Registered host-await builtins (matched by bare function name only)
  3. User-defined functions (matched by package-qualified path)
  4. Standard builtins (matched by bare function name)

Registered names shadow both user-defined functions and standard builtins. This means time.parse_duration_ns can be overridden to route through the host instead of the built-in Rust implementation.

Only unqualified calls are intercepted. Registration matches a call by the name as written in the policy. A bare call — lookup(x) — is intercepted and compiled to a HostAwait. A package-qualified call — data.pkg.lookup(x) — is not intercepted; it is resolved normally, as if the name were never registered.

# "lookup" is registered as a host-await builtin.

package other
import rego.v1
lookup(k) := k            # an ordinary rule that happens to share the name

package demo
import rego.v1
a := lookup(input.k)             # intercepted     -> HostAwait
b := data.other.lookup(input.k)  # NOT intercepted -> calls other.lookup

The qualified form is resolved exactly as it would be without registration: if a rule exists at that path it is called, otherwise compilation fails with Unknown function. (A standard builtin like count has no qualified form at all, so data.pkg.count(x) is always an Unknown function error, registered or not.)

Argument handling: The HostAwait instruction carries a single arg register. Registered builtins must use arg_count: 1; the compiler rejects arg_count > 1 at registration time. To pass multiple values, use object packing: lookup({"user": x, "resource": y}).


Halt instruction

Mnemonic Behaviour Notes
Halt Terminates execution immediately. Used during debugging or emitted for guard rails.

When encountered during run-to-completion execution, Halt returns the current value in register 0.


Parameter data overview

InstructionData (src/rvm/instructions/params.rs) collects all complex parameter types. Each add_* method returns a u16 index suitable for storing inside instructions. The VM retrieves tables via get_* accessors.

Struct Field Purpose
LoopStartParams mode Loop semantics (Any, Every, ForEach).
collection Register holding the iterable collection.
key_reg / value_reg Registers populated with the current key/value each iteration.
result_reg Accumulator for loop outcome (bool for quantifiers).
body_start / loop_end Instruction pointers delimiting the loop body and exit.
BuiltinCallParams dest Register that receives the builtin result.
builtin_index Slot into builtin_info_table for dispatch.
num_args Count of argument registers actually populated.
args[8] Up to eight registers supplying builtin arguments.
FunctionCallParams dest Register that receives the function rule result.
func_rule_index Rule index for the target function definition.
num_args Number of argument registers provided.
args[8] Argument register numbers (unused slots ignored).
ObjectCreateParams dest Destination register for the constructed object.
template_literal_idx Literal template containing all expected keys.
literal_key_fields: Vec<(u16, u8)> Mapping of literal-key indices to value registers.
fields: Vec<(u8, u8)> Dynamic key/value register pairs for non-literal keys.
ArrayCreateParams dest Destination register for the array literal.
elements: Vec<u8> Registers providing array elements (order preserved).
SetCreateParams dest Destination register for the set literal.
elements: Vec<u8> Registers providing set members (duplicates dropped at runtime).
VirtualDataDocumentLookupParams dest Destination register for lookup result.
path_components: Vec<LiteralOrRegister> Ordered path traversal steps; mix of literals and register-based keys.
ChainedIndexParams dest Destination register for resolved value.
root Register containing the root object/collection.
path_components: Vec<LiteralOrRegister> Path components applied relative to the root register.
ComprehensionBeginParams mode Comprehension output type (array, set, object).
collection_reg Source collection register for iteration.
result_reg Register receiving the final collection.
key_reg / value_reg Iteration registers (keys optional for arrays/sets).
body_start / comprehension_end Instruction pointers framing comprehension body and exit.

All parameter structs derive Serialize/Deserialize and can be stored inside artifacts. Some contain Vec fields; the compiler is responsible for ensuring indices remain valid and stable across serialization boundaries.